Asking Questions

Pesach is the holiday where asking questions is encouraged. The focus of the Seder is the מה נשתנה, and we encourage our children to ask as many questions as possible.

Yet, the issue of asking questions among religious, G-d fearing Jews, is a matter of great controversy. This is another area of difference between the rationalists and traditionalists. Both believe in אמונת חכמים, having faith in the authority of the Rabbis. The issue is to what extent are we allowed to question.

Specifically, the subject of potential fallibility in matters of science and astronomy, has very differing views.

The rationalists have no problem in assuming that some of the ideas held by great rabbis in previous generations, have proven to be incorrect. The traditionalists would view such opinions as bordering on heresy. An example would be preconceived notions as to the movement of the sun each day, where even the great Rabbi Yehuda Hanassi is alleged to have acknowledged that the Gentiles were more correct about astronomy.

Rationalists like the Rambam felt that seeking truth by questioning, was a healthy method of understanding Hashem’s universe.

Traditionalists felt that such exploration might cause one to lose his faith. Following the “Rebbe” and trusting his guidance would always set us on the right path.

We ask questions on Pesach. But perhaps these questions are meant for everyone, or maybe just for the children.

Yesterday was three with ספירת העומר.